🔗 Share this article

An acclaimed author, a respected scholar of the American frontier, has written a recent volume titled Brothers of the Gun, which explores the stories of the famed lawman and Doc Holliday. The historian expresses frustration with the famous saying from a renowned movie: “When the myth becomes fact, print the tale.”

“Every researcher cites it, they just beat it to death,” the author remarks happily. “And it’s truly not correct. I composed a story. I aim people to be immersed in the era, but I just get so weary of that quote. The folklore is legend. It won't become fact. People can retell the legend but it can't make it fact.”

That Famous Shootout at the OK Corral

In Tombstone, Arizona, on a day in October 1881, Wyatt Earp and Holliday were involved in a gunfight that is remembered as the Tombstone gunfight. Joined by Earp’s brothers, the duo met the outlaw gang, men sought for robbery and cattle theft. In a brief moment, three Cowboys were dead and Doc was wounded, as were the Earp brothers.

Although being one of numerous frontier conflicts between authorities and bandits, it entered folklore, not least thanks to classic movies including the John Ford film and the Sturges movie.

Uncertainty and Disagreement in Historical Accounts

“A great deal of what we learn about it is confirmable,” Gardner said of the true shootout and its sequels. “But I always go back to one of the most telling quotes, and it’s a very plain comment. A dressmaker, who witnessed the confrontation, said: ‘I don’t know. It was all a blur.’”

Even the individuals present had varying accounts. Testimony from the Spicer hearing is additionally confusing. Witnesses who were friends of the outlaws were lying, and all version is a bit distinct. It’s rare when somebody aligns on any point.

“It was all a blur.” – an eyewitness

“Even the people present were bewildered,” Gardner continues. “So it’s truly challenging to determine it, and it took place in a brief moment.”

Myth-Making and Cinema Portrayals

The lawman survived into the Hollywood age, dying in the late 1920s at the years of eight decades. First depicted on a silent film screen in 1923, he eventually became the subject of major classic movies. In relatively recent years, he has been portrayed by Kurt Russell in the 1993 film and another actor in Wyatt Earp.

Gardner delves through such myth-making to reveal the men underneath. His publications span the range of the Wild West, from a legendary figure and his pursuer to Jesse James.

Layered Backgrounds of Wyatt Earp and Holliday

Hailing in Illinois in 1848, Earp was underage to serve in the civil war, though he attempted to do so. When he was twenty, he became a law officer in Lamar, Missouri. Mistakes were done. He experienced a calamity with the death of his spouse, Urilla, from illness in the 1870s. Later, as constable, he retained public funds he collected.

“We do not know why he held it,” Gardner states. “He flees, and finds himself in Oklahoma. He’s apprehended for taking a horse, and then he’s in the state, and he’s running a brothel. In time he heads back to the frontier, and he settles in a booming town.”

Regardless of his troubled past, Wyatt excelled as a police officer. Local papers applauded him often. In one example, he apprehended a intoxicated man who had money on him. He held the funds for the drunk and gave it back when he released him from custody.

Different Natures of the Pair

Gardner emphasizes the stark difference between the pair. Earp was aspiring, seeking to better himself and reach positions like county sheriff. Doc, hailing in the South in 1851, was a tooth doctor turned risk-taker. Unlike Wyatt, he never display signs of establishing roots.

“He just journeys from one saloon to the following,” Gardner notes. “He doesn't really change. And part of that’s his obsession to gambling. Some of that is his illness, coping with that and using substances, whether it’s with drink or later laudanum.”

Legacy and Academic Importance

Brothers of the Gun illustrates a fascinating aspect of the old west: the friction between law and chaos, and the attempts of authorities to impose rule over developing communities. The degree of procedure that resulted from a shootout – hearings, statements, decrees for payment – might astonish those acquainted with romanticized depictions of the time.

Furthermore, Wyatt and Doc were entangled in partisan political struggles. He was a member of the GOP, while Tombstone sheriff a Democrat was a Democrat, creating a competition for influence and office.

In the end, Gardner declines to idealize these men. Wyatt and Doc lived periods on each side